From Bar Pie to Dessert Pie: A Guide to 21 Pizza Styles to Try

Pies are the only option for chefs and consumers who want to vary their fillings. But it all comes down to 20 types of pies to fill, bake and enjoy. (Staten Island Advance/Lauren Lovallo)

STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — With dough, sauce and cheese, pizza can be an endless palette for the artisan. And as sure as the pizza maker knows how to make it, the curious and gourmet palates will come.

Here are 21 styles of pizza, most of which originate from the rich cuisines of Staten Island. Warning: do not read this on an empty stomach.

Pizza

A margarita pie from Pier 76, St. George (Staten Island Advance/Hilton Flores) Staten Island AdvanceAdvance on Staten Island

1.) Daisy Pie — Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil with the sauce poured and pooled on top.

Classic New York Slice Pizza

A perfect slice of New York pizza — a “beats” — from North Shore Pizza in Port Richmond (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)Pamela Silvestri

2.) New York style — Made with low-moisture mozzarella that bubbles and marries into a marbled fusion of sauce and cheese; the crust is notable for its chewy interior and crisp exterior.

Pizza

Joe & Pat’s Neapolitan Pie with a Super Thin Crust (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)advance on Staten Island

3.) Neapolitan — Made with fresh mozzarella and fresh tomato sauce — preferably from the Naples region of Italy — it has specific flour characteristics that result in a fragrant, supple dough and a patina pattern on top.

On the Pizza Trail: Take a Tasty Hike to These 6 Spots Whether you're traveling by train or car/bike, here are the standout restaurants we recommend in a borough filled with great pizza

A Share of Lee (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)Sylvester

4.) Tavern Pie —A notable variation where the cheese is placed directly on the dough, then applied with toppings and, finally, a light ladle of sauce to finish; this tart does not travel well and is best eaten fresh from the oven.

Festivals

A bar pie at most: Mortadella on pistachio cream sauce and stracciatella cheese with peppadu peppers at Mona Lisa in Annadale (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)Staff shooting

5.) Sea bass pie — less than 10 inches in diameter with trim extending about a finger’s length to the rim.

Pizza

A white pie from Bario in New Springville (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

6.) White — A perfect balance of roasted cheese with olive oil for a smooth shine or pockets of fresh ricotta on top.

Pizza

Clam pie is a classic staple at the Road House in Sunnyside. (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

7.) Clam Pie — Chunks of clams pair with a white tart brushed with a generous dose of garlic and olive oil.

Thick Crust Pie

Al’s thick-crust pizza in Great Kills (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)

8.) Hollow dish — A round pie with a thick crust and a heavy dose of sauce and cheese.

Casa Nino's Pizza Bar

Casa Nino’s Pizza Bar’s garbage pie with four kinds of meat, three different vegetables and lots of cheese underneath (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)

9.) Garbage Pie — A pizza absolutely loaded with toppings — like everything — onions, mushrooms, peppers, olives and/or anchovies, meatballs and sausages.

Chicken pizza and Caesar salad from Palermo Pizzeria in Richmond Valley. (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

10.) California style aka “salad pie” — Typically a thin-crust pie topped with green vegetables or raw toppings straight from the oven.

The Best of Vodka Pizza

Port Richmond’s Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe serves up a delicious charred pie (Staten Island Advance/Shane DiMaio)Shane DiMaio

11.) To the coal — The crust has a pleasant, bold charcoal and ash flavor, both of which complement the creamy, acidic toppings; it’s best enjoyed at a restaurant.

The Goodfellas

A smoked Goodfellas pie fresh from the wood-fired oven (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

12.) Brick wood-fired oven — There is smoke in the mouth, a deliciousness with the dough and the fillings that become more vibrant with the woody background. Vodka pies are ideal accompanied by wood pies.

Pizza Turtles

Tortugas Pizza has two locations in the Birmingham metro area, serving Chicago-style deep-dish pizza. (Advance file photo by Hal Yeager)(AL.com file photo/Hal Yeager)

13.) Chicago Style —A deep-dish pie stuffed with hearty cheese and thick tomato sauce with a wide-rimmed crust.

Pronto

Pronto pizzas are best when it’s a generous slice of skillet pie (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

14.) Bread Pie — Thick on the crust edge leading to a sunken cluster of cheese and toppings, the dough is sturdy (yet airy and flavorful) enough to hold a myriad of heavy toppings like cheesesteak, buffalo chicken, and cooked spinach plus plenty of fresh mozzarella.

The best pizza brothers lfs

To illustrate the grandmother’s slice, here’s Brother’s of Port Richmond (Staten Island Advance/Lauren Lovallo)

15.) Grandma — A square pie with a relatively thin, biscuit-like crust, usually notable for a striped arrangement of sauce and cheese; the sauce is often sweet, as opposed to savory.

Pizza

Also from Brother’s Pizza in Port Richmond with its famous Sicilian slices. Look at them side by side with a slice from Grandma to see the difference in crust. (Staten Island Advance/Lauren Lovallo) (Staten Island Advance/Lauren Lo

16.) Sicilian — Square tart with a dense, thick dough base, almost like focaccia; the salty tomato sauce is on top (as opposed to grandma’s typical sweeter sauce); can also be called an L&B tart, a nod to the Brooklyn shop that does this style so well.

Focaccia

Foccacia from Bruno’s Bakery in Freehold, NJ (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)

17.) Focaccia — A square creation with a softer, fluffier dough than the Sicilian and the delicious mouthfeel of a dough drizzled with olive oil.

An anchovy sits on a slice of sfincione pizza at Pizza Doughnais, which opened in November in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Southeast Portland. Co-owners Jessica and Justin Donais serve Sicilian-style pizza with square slices. Dave Killen / staff - Pizza Doughnais in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Southeast Portland Dave Killen

Perfectly illustrated: An anchovy sits atop a slice of breadcrumb-topped sfincione at Pizza Doughnais in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Southeast Portland. (Advance file photo by Dave Killen)Dave Killen

18.) Fincione — Topped with crushed breadcrumbs with or without anchovies and roasted with Caciocavallo cheese and extra virgin olive oil.

Oaxacan cold cuts

Mexican pizza from Oaxaca Taqueria in West Brighton (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)

19.) Mexican Pie — When pizza is a sideline for a restaurant that’s primarily a taqueria, it produces pies with taco ingredients like avocado, pico di gallo and chorizo.

Pizza

The Richmond’s chicken parmesan pie is incredibly delicious. (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Courtesy of Megan Lovallo)

20.) Chicken Parmesan Pie — The actual “crust” is made mostly of ground chicken and topped like a pizza. The meat cooks on the bottom and essentially fries the whole thing.

Nutella Tarts

Millie’s Meatballs of Charleston offers a Nutella-filled pie topped with cannoli cream, ice cream or fresh whipped cream (Staten Island Advance/Pamela Silvestri)(Staten Island Advance/Pamela Si

21.) Dessert pie — topped or filled with Nutella. Accompaniments or additions may include cannoli cream, French cream, whipped cream, or ice cream.

Pamela Silvestri, a Staten Island native and pizza enthusiast, is the editor-in-chief of Advance Food. You can contact her at: silvestri@siadvance.com.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *